Ada 2022 Issues Voting and Discussion Index

This is an index of all Ada 2022 Issues. Priority is Very Low, Low, Medium, High, or Critical; Difficulty is Easy, Medium, or Hard. Some AIs have alternatives; these are used when the best solution is not apparent. Alternatives share the AI number, but have a different alternative number (following the second dash). Each AI is followed by an index of the discussions and/or voting that occurred at meetings or by Letter Ballots. The index includes a link directly to the discussion in the appropriate set of minutes. For issues that probably will not be considered by the ARG, look in the Ada Commentaries Index. For Ada 95 issues that have or will be considered by the ARG, look in the Ada 95 Issues Index. For Ada 2005 issues that have or will be considered by the ARG, look in the Ada 2005 Issues Index. For Ada 2012 issues that have or will be considered by the ARG, look in the Ada 2012 Issues Index.

The Ada 2022 Issues are indexed in numeric order, by the class of issue, by the current status, and by the section referenced.

Including discussion and voting information

AI22-0001-1/03   2022-01-07 -- Presentation issues in Ada 202x submission
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Presentation                Status: Deleted      21-01-19
    RM References:  3.09 (21)   3.09.03 (8/3)   4.02.01 (7/5)   4.03.05 (7/5)   4.03.05 (8/5)   4.03.05 (9/5)   4.03.05 (22/5)   13.01.01 (18.8/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Approve AI w/ changes: 13-0-0

AI22-0002-1/03   2021-11-18 -- Nonoverridable aspects must be primitive
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Medium
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-01-14
    RM References:  13.01.01 (18.3/5)   4.03.05 (6/5)   4.03.05 (10/5)   4.03.05 (35/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Approve AI: 12-0-0
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Intent: 13-0-0

AI22-0003-1/03   2022-01-14 -- Vestigial rule about inheritance of user-defined literal aspects
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-01-14
    RM References:  4.02.01 (14/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Approve AI w/ changes: 11-0-0

AI22-0004-1/04   2022-02-03 -- Permissions of 4.1.4 and No_Implementation_Attributes
    Priority: Very Low   Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-02-03
    RM References:  13.12.01 (2/2)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 16-0-0
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Discussed

AI22-0005-1/00   2021-11-11 -- Editorial comments on AARM 2022
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Confirmation                Status: Received     21-11-11
    RM References:  6.06 (6)

AI22-0006-1/03   2022-01-14 -- Two-pass iteration for array aggregates
    Priority: Medium     Difficulty: Medium
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-01-14
    RM References:  4.03.03 (20.3/5)   4.03.03 (20.4/5)   4.03.03 (32/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Approve AI w/ changes: 12-0-0

AI22-0007-1/03   2022-01-19 -- Discriminant checks for aggregates might need to be done early
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-01-19
    RM References:  4.03 (6)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Approve AI w/ changes: 11-0-0

AI22-0008-1/03   2022-02-03 -- Nominal subtype of a delta aggregate
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-02-03
    RM References:  4.03.03 (14.1/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI: 16-0-0
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Intent: 11-0-0

AI22-0009-1/02   2022-06-21 -- Nonvolatile views of volatile objects
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    21-11-11
    RM References:  4.06 (58.4/5)   C.06 (12/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Intent: 13-0-1

AI22-0010-1/04   2022-01-14 -- Predicates on private extensions
    Priority: Medium     Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-01-14
    RM References:  7.03 (13)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Approve AI w/ changes: 12-0-0

AI22-0011-1/05   2022-01-19 -- Reduction expression issues
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-01-19
    RM References:  4.05.10 (9/5)   4.05.10 (10/5)   4.05.10 (12/5)   4.05.10 (13/5)   4.05.10 (15/5)   4.05.10 (16/5)   4.05.10 (17/5)   4.05.10 (18/5)
                    4.05.10 (19/5)   4.05.10 (20/5)   4.05.10 (24/5)   4.05.10 (25/5)   4.05.10 (27/5)   4.05.10 (29/5)   4.05.10 (34/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Approve AI w/ changes: 11-0-0

AI22-0012-1/03   2022-01-14 -- Incompatibility for abstract type Pre'Class
    Priority: Medium     Difficulty: Hard
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-01-14
    RM References:  6.01.01 (18.2/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Approve AI w/ changes: 10-0-2

AI22-0013-1/01   2021-11-12 -- Pragma after a final label
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: No Action    16-0-0  22-02-03
    RM References:  5.01 (12.1/3)   5.06 (1)   5.06 (2)   5.06 (3)   5.06 (4)   5.06 (5)   5.06 (6)  
    Alternatives:   AI22-0013-2
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - No Action: 16-0-0
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Discussed

AI22-0013-2/02   2022-02-03 -- Pragma after a final label
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-02-03
    RM References:  5.01 (12.1/3)   2.08 (12)  
    Alternatives:   AI22-0013-1
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI: 16-0-0

AI22-0014-1/02   2022-02-03 -- Predicates on inherited functions
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-02-03
    RM References:  3.04 (27/2)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 15-0-1

AI22-0015-1/01   2021-11-12 -- Innermost master of the call is ambiguous
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    21-11-12
    RM References:  3.09 (26.1/3)   3.10.02 (14/3)   7.06.01 (11.3/3)   7.06.01 (11.4/3)

AI22-0016-1/02   2022-02-03 -- Newly constructed objects in a declare expression
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-02-03
    RM References:  4.05.09 (6/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI: 14-0-0

AI22-0017-1/00   2021-11-12 -- Accessibility level of an object in a declare expression
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Hard
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    21-11-12
    RM References:  3.10.02 (7/5)   4.05.09 (7/5)

AI22-0018-1/04   2022-01-14 -- Easy fixes to Ada 2022
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-01-14
    RM References:  4.03.05 (24/5)   4.03.05 (26/5)   4.03.05 (38/5)   4.03.05 (39/5)   4.09 (8.1/5)   13.01 (0.1/3)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62M, Nov 2021 - Approve AI w/ changes: 13-0-0

AI22-0019-1/03   2023-06-24 -- Freezing of aspect specifications
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-23
    RM References:  13.01.01 (13.1/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 14-0-1
        Meeting 62P, May 2022 - Intent: 13-0-0

AI22-0020-1/02   2022-01-13 -- Order of elements in Aggregate aspect
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Ramification                Status: ARG Approved 15-0-1  22-02-03
    RM References:  4.03.05 (3/5)   4.03.05 (4/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI: 15-0-1

AI22-0021-1/03   2022-02-03 -- Aggregate aspect resolution should not be too smart
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-02-03
    RM References:  4.03.05 (7/5)   4.03.05 (8/5)   4.03.05 (9/5)   4.03.05 (11/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 16-0-0

AI22-0022-1/01   2022-01-17 -- Difficult example issues from WG 9 review
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Presentation                Status: Received     21-05-20
    RM References:  4.03.05 (93/5)   9.02 (26)   9.02 (27)   9.05.02 (33)   9.05.02 (35)   9.05.02 (36)   9.05.02 (37)   A.18.33 (3/3)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Intent: 16-0-0

AI22-0023-1/02   2022-02-04 -- Deferred presentation issues from the WG 9 review
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Presentation                Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-02-03
    RM References:  1.01.02 (35)   3.08 (18/2)   7.03.02 (5/5)   9.02 (7)   10.02.01 (18/3)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 16-0-0

AI22-0024-1/01   2022-01-20 -- Abstract prefixed views
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    22-01-20
    RM References:  3.09.03 (7/5)   4.01.03 (9.2/3)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Discussed

AI22-0025-1/02   2022-01-21 -- Accessibility of generalized iterators
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Ramification                Status: Work Item    22-01-20
    RM References:  5.05.02 (8/3)   5.05.02 (10/5)

AI22-0026-1/01   2022-01-21 -- Problem with nested type extension check
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    22-01-21
    RM References:  4.08 (10.1/3)

AI22-0027-1/04   2022-06-23 -- Primitive equality of a class-wide type
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-23
    RM References:  3.04.01 (5)   4.05.02 (28.1/5)   12.05.01 (23.2/2)   12.06 (9.2/3)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 15-0-0

AI22-0028-1/04   2022-06-14 -- Program_Error for unchecked union equality
    Priority: Very Low   Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-14
    RM References:  B.03.03 (22/2)   B.03.03 (23/2)   B.03.03 (24/2)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62P, May 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 13-0-1
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Discussed

AI22-0029-1/04   2022-06-23 -- External_Tag collisions
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Medium
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-23
    RM References:  13.03 (75.1/3)   13.03 (76)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 14-0-0
        Meeting 62P, May 2022 - Intent: 14-0-0

AI22-0030-1/02   2022-01-26 -- Array iterators of slices
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-05-05
    RM References:  5.05.02 (6.1/4)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62P, May 2022 - Approve AI: 13-0-0

AI22-0031-1/03   2022-02-03 -- Issues with dynamic evaluation of container aggregates
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-02-03
    RM References:  4.03.05 (44/5)   4.03.05 (46/5)   4.03.05 (53/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 16-0-0

AI22-0032-1/04   2022-02-04 -- Abstract and class-wide container aggregates
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-02-03
    RM References:  4.03 (4/5)   4.03.05 (11/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 16-0-0

AI22-0033-1/03   2022-01-26 -- If it ain't broke...
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Confirmation                Status: Received     22-01-26
    RM References:  3.02.04 (21/3)   3.03 (11)   3.03 (25/3)   4.04 (7/3)   5.08 (5)   8.05.01 (6)   12.02 (2)   A.10.08 (8)
                    A.10.09 (13)

AI22-0034-1/01   2022-01-26 -- Implementation model of dynamic accessibility checking
    Priority: Medium     Difficulty: Hard
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    22-01-26
    RM References:  3.10.02 (22)

AI22-0035-1/02   2022-04-25 -- Add "not null" to some Ada.Strings subprograms
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022  22-05-05
    RM References:  A.04.03 (109)   A.04.03 (8.2/2)   A.04.03 (10)   A.04.03 (14)   A.04.03 (20)   A.04.03 (21)   A.04.03 (56.1/2)   A.04.03 (57)
                    A.04.03 (63)   A.04.03 (69)   A.04.03 (71)   A.04.04 (43.2/2)   A.04.04 (45)   A.04.04 (49)   A.04.04 (55)   A.04.04 (56)
                    A.04.05 (38.2/2)   A.04.05 (40)   A.04.05 (44)   A.04.05 (50)   A.04.05 (51)  
    Alternatives:   AI22-0035-2
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62P, May 2022 - Approve AI: 13-0-0
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Intent: 16-0-0

AI22-0035-2/01   2022-04-25 -- Add "not null" to type Character_Mapping_Function
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: No Action     13-0-0   22-05-05
    RM References:  A.04.02 (25)  
    Alternatives:   AI22-0035-1
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62P, May 2022 - No Action: 13-0-0

AI22-0036-1/02   2022-04-26 -- Attributes in the expression of Default_Value
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    22-01-26
    RM References:  3.05 (56.3/3)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Discussed
        Meeting 62N, Feb 2022 - Intent: 14-0-2

AI22-0037-1/02   2022-06-23 -- Freezing of static expressions
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Ramification                Status: ARG Approved 14-0-1  22-06-23
    RM References:  13.14 (7.2/5)   13.14 (8/4)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 14-0-1

AI22-0038-1/04   2022-06-23 -- Introduction to 7.3.2
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Presentation                Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-23
    RM References:  7.03.02 (1/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 13-0-0
        Meeting 62P, May 2022 - Intent: 13-0-0

AI22-0039-1/03   2022-06-14 -- Clarify 8.3(26/2)
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Presentation                Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-14
    RM References:  8.03 (26/2)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62P, May 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 13-0-0

AI22-0040-1/02   2022-03-22 -- Finalization and Implicit Loops
    Priority: Medium     Difficulty: Medium
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    22-03-04
    RM References:  7.06.01 (3)   4.04 (9.7)   6.06.01 (22.12)   7.06 (18)   7.06.01 (13.1)

AI22-0041-1/03   2022-06-23 -- Deferred constant subtype compatibility
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-23
    RM References:  7.04 (6/3)   7.04 (7/2)   7.04 (7.1/2)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 15-0-0

AI22-0042-1/02   2022-06-23 -- Freezing rule needed for dispatching expression functions
    Priority: High       Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-23
    RM References:  13.14 (15.1/3)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Approve AI: 14-0-1

AI22-0043-1/01   2022-06-15 -- Look through more than parens and qualified exprs to get tag fortag-indeterminat
    Priority: Medium     Difficulty: Medium
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    22-06-15
    RM References:  3.09.02 (17/2)   3.09.02 (18/2)   3.09.02 (18.1/2)   3.09.02 (19)

AI22-0044-1/02   2022-06-23 -- Aggregate discriminants that do not satisfy predicates
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-23
    RM References:  4.03.01 (17/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 14-0-1

AI22-0045-1/01   2022-06-16 -- Issues with pragma placement
    Priority: Medium     Difficulty: Medium
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Work Item    22-06-16
    RM References:  2.08 (6/5)   2.08 (7/3)   2.08 (7.1/3)   2.08 (7.2/3)   2.08 (12)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Discussed

AI22-0046-1/02   2022-06-23 -- Statically names misses some cases
    Priority: Low        Difficulty: Easy
    Class: Binding Interpretation      Status: Corrigendum 1 for Ada 2022 22-06-23
    RM References:  4.09 (17.3/5)  
    Discussions and/or Voting: 
        Meeting 62Q, Jun 2022 - Approve AI w/ changes: 15-0-0

Ada 2022 Issues listed in numeric order

Including discussion and voting information